May 25, 2008

Cardboard Mysteries

This post was inspired by an email from Reader Paul in Ottawa:

In 1966, an early checklist listed card 115 as Warren Spahn. This was corrected on later issues as Bill Henry and it is in fact the Henry card that is in circulation...but it begs the question, is there a 1966 Spahn card out there? Clearly Topps was expecting him to return to the Giants for the 1966 season, and it it also clear that his retirement created the switch...but if it was so late that SOME CHECKLISTS LISTED HIM AS THE CARD, is it possible that Topps has a stash of cards made that they didn't release into circulation? It is obvious that at least they would have had a plate for this card.

Anyone out there ever heard of such a card?



While I'm not sure what the answer is to this question, it made me think of other instances that I've dubbed Cardboard Mysteries.

• Where's Steve Carlton in the 1966 Topps set?

• What was the real reason Bowman almost released Ted Williams as card #66 in its 1954 set?


• How did Fleer get so many big names for their 1963 set? Or can we chalk it up to an especially talkative Jimmy Piersall?

• Topps has made at least five cards that are either post career-ending accident or 'In Memoriam' cards, including: Ken Hubbs (1964), Cory Lidle (2006), A. Bartlett Giamatti (1990), Roberto Clemente (1973) and Roy Campanella's 'Symbol of Courage' (1959). So why didn't they do one for Thurman Munson in 1980 Topps?

• Also regarding Munson, Thurman's 1971 Topps card is his second-year card, yet it's more expensive than his rookie. Are there other instances where this occurs?

4 comments:

dayf said...

Steve Carlton also got printed on a 1988 Topps checklist before he was pulled from the set.

"Thurman's 1971 Topps card is his second-year card, yet it's more expensive than his rookie. Are there other instances where this occurs?"

Chipper Jones' 1992 Bowman card has always blown away all his 1991 rookies.

I'd personally give an eye tooth to know what 6 players were pulled from the 1953 Topps set.

sgarveyfan said...

1972 Topps Steve Garvey is worth more than his 1971 rookie.

Donald said...

Ron Cey 1973 is more expensive than his 1972 rookie. Of course his 1973 also includes some guy named Mike Schmidt.

Andy said...

On more for the memoriam list - Jim Umbricht's 1964 card says that he passed away in April (he had cancer). It's in Series 5 so they probably had time pull it put I would guess chose not to...