August 27, 2006

Manager for a Day

Wouldn’t it be cool if you could call up a major league manager whenever you had a big decision to make? Or if you could hire one out for the day and he would show up in his uniform, with spikes, and just follow you around everywhere, offering advice and constantly giving you weird hand signals? I think that would rock. If it were really something you could do, I would want Earl Weaver to follow me around. And if Earl weren’t available, I’d want Al Lopez.

Imagine it, you’re behind a lady at the corner store and she’s paying in nickels and pennies and you go to Lopez for the sign and he flashes you ‘steal’. Then, if the guy behind the counter chases you out, Al could distract him with an argument or by kicking dirt on the guy’s shoes.

They could be called Decisions for Hire, or something like that, and could be available as legal representation, or to take the heat for you when you fuck up. I personally think it would be great to be able to screw up dinner and then have Joe Torre hold a press conference and deflect the fault away from me.

Getting a personal manager would be just like being a child again. Don’t want to go to work? Get Zim to call in sick for you. Need to practice spitting? I just saw LaRussa amble by; I’m sure he’s free. Couldn’t secure a clown for your kid’s birthday party? There’s nothing like an afternoon with Frank Robinson. Don’t know where your motivation’s gone? There’s a whole stable of inspiring pep talkers just a phone call away.

Besides, if they don’t give good advice, or if you have an especially bad day, you can always fire them. And if that’s your thing, just ask for ‘The Fire Sale’, Jim Lemon and Billy Martin—two for the price of one!

New Numbers: #301 - 598

307. Gary Peters, White Sox
310. Bob Allison, Twins
311. Red Sox Rookies (Ken Brett/Sparky Lyle)
315. Sherm Lollar, White Sox
319. Paul Blair, Orioles
323. Jose Santiago, Red Sox
325. Vic Davalillo, Indians
341. Wilbur Wood, White Sox
346. Jim Perry, Twins
349. Joe Pepitone, Yankees
352. Checklist 4
359. Chico Ruiz, Reds
360. Bill Skowron, Yankees
365. Stu Miller, Orioles
367. Leon Wagner, Indians
368. Minnie Minoso, White Sox
373. Davey Johnson, Orioles
374. Bob Tillman, Red Sox
375. Ken Boyer, Cardinals
381. Chuck Essegian, Indians
382. Bobby del Greco, Phillies
387. Check Estrada, Orioles
390. Bill Freehan, Tigers
391. Joe Foy, Red Sox
392. Tommy Harper, Reds
395. Chris Short, Phillies
398. Al Downing, Yankees
400. Juan Marichal, Giants (I moved Marichal to a more important number after reevaluating his role and worth to the Topps sets of the decade)
404. Andy Etchebarren, Orioles
405. Floyd Robinson, White Sox
406. Checklist 5
420. Jim Maloney, Reds
426. Lou Clinton, Red Sox
427. Dick Ellsworth, Cubs
429-438. Highlights
444. Joe Nuxhall, Reds
447. Felix Mantilla, Red Sox
449. Jerry Adair, Orioles
455. Norm Cash, Tigers
459. Curt Blefary, Orioles
460. Joe Torre, Braves
461. Dalton Jones, Red Sox
465. Jim O’Toole, Reds
469. Clete Boyer, Yankees
473. Jim Lonborg, Red Sox
477. Tommy John, White Sox
482. Bill Monbouquette, Red Sox
484. Jim Landis, White Sox
488. Ruben Amaro, Phillies
490. Gus Triandos, Orioles
498. Don Buford, White Sox
507. Johnny Edwards, Reds
516. Joe Azcue, Indians
527. Eddie Bressoud, Red Sox
529. Lew Burdette, Braves
533. Tito Francona, Indians
537. Checklist 6
540. Curt Flood, Cardinals
544. Phil Linz, Yankees
545. Hoyt Wilhelm, White Sox
548. Lee Strange, Red Sox
551. Bob Purkey, Reds
562. Jim Bouton, Yankees
563. Dick Radatz, Red Sox
569. Bill Henry, Reds
570. Ferguson Jenkins, Cubs
578. Tony Gonzalez, Phillies
579. Bill Skowron, AL AS
580. Nellie Fox, AL AS
581. Luis Aparicio, AL AS
582. Brooks Robinson, AL AS
583. Carl Yastzremski, AL AS
584. Mickey Mantle, AL AS
585. Frank Robinson, AL AS
586. Elston Howard, AL AS
587. Denny McLain, AL AS
588. Whitey Ford, AL AS
589. Willie McCovey, NL AS
590. Bill Mazeroski, NL AS
591. Maury Wills, NL AS
592. Ken Boyer, NL AS
593. Roberto Clemente, NL AS
594. Willie Mays, NL AS
595. Hank Aaron, NL AS
596. Joe Torre, NL AS
597. Bob Gibson, NL AS
598. Warren Spahn, NL AS

August 22, 2006

A Week's Worth

Here’s to You, Warren Brusstar

What is life’s greatest puzzle? Of course it’s one of those things that depends on who you ask. A teenage boy may tell you it’s removing a bra with one hand. Wesley Snipes may tell you it’s figuring out who found out he wasn’t paying taxes. But if you wanted to make a general list—and who doesn’t like making lists?—I would bet that the construction of the pyramids, the hanging gardens of Babylon and the Celtics’ lack of draft-day prowess in 1993 when they took Eric Montross over Eddie Jones would be on there. If the list was more extensive, you could even find a place for Warren Brusstar’s sloppy chest hair shave on his card from '78, the unexplained flameouts of Kevin Maas, Troy Neel and/or the incredibly brief flash that was Vaughn Eshelman. But I would guess that figuring out an average Topps checklist for an entire decade would probably not make the list, though it is definitely deserving (it’s a lot harder than it looks).

New Numbers: #1 - 300

#1 Clemente/T. Davis/Rose (NL Batting Leaders)
#2 Oliva/Runnels/Yastzremski (AL Batting Leaders)
#3 Aaron/Mays/McCovey (NL HR Leaders)
#4 Killebrew/Maris/Yastzremski (AL HR Leaders)
#5 Aaron/Cepeda/McCovey (NL RBI Leaders)
#6 Killebrew/Maris/F. Robinson (AL RBI Leaders)
#7 Koufax/Marichal/Spahn (NL Pitching Leaders)
#8 Ford/McClain/J. Perry (AL Pitching Leaders)
#9 Gibson/Koufax/P. Niekro (NL ERA Leaders)
#10 Chance/Peters/Tiant (AL ERA Leaders)
#11 Drysdale/Jenkins/Koufax (NL SO Leaders)
#12 Lonborg/McDowell/Pascual (AL SO Leaders)
#15 Robin Roberts, Orioles (change from Phillies)
#16 Willie Kirkland, Indians
#17 Johnny Callison, Phillies
#19 Zoilo Versalles, Twins
#23 Mike Ryan, Red Sox
#25 Roy Sievers, White Sox
#27 Checklist 1
#33 Jackie Brandt, Orioles
#36 Bobby Wine, Phillies
#42 Chuck Schilling, Red Sox
#51 Pete Richert, Orioles
#55 Max Alvis, Indians
#60 Willie Horton, Tigers
#63 Gary Geiger, Red Sox
#68 Don Demeter, Phillies
#75 Milt Pappas, Reds
#76 Earl Wilson, Red Sox
#81 Sam Bowens, Orioles
#88 Frank Funk, Indians
#89 Boog Powell, Orioles
#93 Larry Jackson, Phillies
#101 Dallas Green, Phillies
#112 Steve Barber, Orioles
#114 Dick Donovan, Indians
#121 JC Martin, White Sox
#123 Don McMahon, Indians
#124 John Boozer, Phillies
#126-135 Babe Ruth Special
#138 Art Mahaffrey, Phillies
#140 Tony Conigliaro, Red Sox
#141 Tommy McCraw, White Sox
#143 Dave McNally, Orioles
#146 Checklist 2
#158 Wes Covington, Phillies
#162 Reggie Smith, Red Sox
#170 Del Crandall, Braves
#177 Bubba Phillips, Indians
#191 Clay Darlymple, Phillies
#196 Dick Hall, Orioles
#201 Larry Brown, Phillies
#203 Russ Snyder, Orioles
#211 Woodie Fryman, Phillies
#212 Dave Morehead, Red Sox
#220 Billy Pierce, Giants
#221 Cookie Rojas, Phillies
#230-239 World Series Special (a card for each year)
#245 Frank Malzone, Red Sox
#252 White Sox Rookies (Mike Hershberger/Carlos May)
#256 Woodie Held, Indians
#259 Juan Pizarro, White Sox
#265 Jim Bunning, Phillies
#270 Jim Gentile, Orioles
#272 Phillies Rookies (Ray Culp/Rick Wise)
#277 Checklist 3
#280 Dick Stuart, Red Sox
#283 Johnny Briggs, Phillies
#290 Jim Kaat, Twins
#296 Tony Taylor, Phillies
#298 Rico Petrocelli, Red Sox

So I’m only reporting number assignments between 1 and 300 (for now), because it’s just too many to list at once. Also, I hope it’s not too painfully obvious that I only worked on the Orioles, Red Sox, Phillies, White Sox and Indians and a few bigger names. I’ll list new numbers from 300 to 598 later this week.


Grizzly Guillermo

One of my glowing achievements in high school was that not only did I not take any honors-level classes, but I also failed Spanish and subsequently dropped learning the language. So it only follows that it took me until just this past weekend to learn that ‘William’ in Spanish is ‘Guillermo’. Thus, ‘Guillermo Hernandez’ is in fact the very same ‘Willie Hernandez’ who won the Cy Young and the MVP and had the teddy-bear haircut (look at his headshot and squint, you’ll see what I mean about those tufts skirting out from under his cap). I know, I know, I’m an idiot. Hey, do you think that maybe he moved to the wilds of Puerto Rico after retiring and let his hair grow out, then groomed it out to look more like two well-proportioned bear ears off his head, let the hair grow over his real ears and down past his shoulders and even beyond, down past his elbows, grew his fingernails real, real long and plastered his hair to look like fur, then filed down his incisors, gained a lot of weight and lived off the land? Maybe, if he had kids, they could sell tickets to drunk spring-breakers to watch him kill a fish with his hands and teeth while he waded through a brook. And then, after a late lunch of raw fish, Guillermo could try to teach the guava spider and the coqui frog to intimidate the other animals with a good brushback pitch.


File Under: Muppet

Dave Lemanczyk, you are a Muppet, perhaps even the basis for the great Fraggle Rock character Red. Tim McCarver, you a tired old Muppet, one with plenty of fleshy foam in the face. This is really one of the most unflattering photos ever taken. If I were Tim McCarver, I'd make sure Joe Morgan or some other rival jealous tv commentator doesn't get their hands on this; it has the potential to fuel the fire of a drunken, on-air rant. Or better yet, this card should be kept on file at every network news department, just in case McCarver ever gets busted for something, like if he were in town for a Dodger game and got caught on a security camera committing petty shoplifting on Rodeo Drive. If that ever were to happen and someone printed t-shirts coming to his support, I may be forced to buy one (but only as long as the graphic artist agrees to use the headshot from this hideous card).



Hair, Glorious Hair!

OK, a long time ago, before you were born, I said that there should be a Sports Hair Hall of Fame. It wasn’t fully fleshed out back then, only that Oscar Gamble, Garry Maddox and Al Hrabosky would be among the inaugural class of inductees. Well, I have another prize example to induct.

I’d like to welcome Bruce Sutter’s beard. Sutter’s Beard had a distinguished career, saving a fat face from a paper bag in the late Seventies, being the model for a perfect phone receiver shelf for adult men in need of hands-free talking and, of course, lulling opposing late-inning hitters with its gentle but deadly wheat-in-the-breeze undulation. Quite possibly the only major-league hair worthy of its own endorsement deal. How about: It’s never too late for Pomade!


Oh! Those Crazy Base-Ball Players! They Think They’re Soooo Great!

Canseco’s latest jump to pitcher wasn’t the first time he made a dumb move on the mound. He's made others, like the one captured here, from 1993. Also, Pete Vuckovich grips his bat like a little girl. Or perhaps, like a bendy toy (you know, one of those rubber toys with the really long arms and legs). It’s like Red Schoendienst told him it would be really good for him to get in the groove by sleeping with his bat the night before and all his muscles were still asleep when they took this photo. How much you want to bet that the respective Score and Donruss photographers got some kind of slap on the back from their bosses while their bosses grinned with their top teeth exposed and shook their heads in disbelief? I think there’s a pretty good chance.


The Fantastic Card of the Day

Maury Wills was a bona fide All-Star who could end up in the Hall of Fame. (Repeat this after you read the next few sentences). OK, so here’s why this is the Fantastic Card of the Day: this 1962 Topps card of him, featured on this Turn Back the Clock card from 1987, this one of him on the Dodgers, with the woodgrained background was never made. Wills was one of the very few players that Topps didn’t sign to a contract, because they didn’t think he’d make it to the majors. How messed up is that? Today they give nearly every draft pick a card. But not that Maury Wills; I just don’t think he’ll make it to the majors.

August 13, 2006

Forget #1–Who’s #285?

Last week, as I lazily moved from one destination to the next around Northern Vermont, I got to thinking: did Topps create Mickey Mantle, or did The Mick create Topps? (In the public consciousness, I mean). And if the former is true, couldn’t it also be said that Topps either created to help to mold the popularity (and possibly career) swings of every other baseball player since 1951? These questions got me (in a roundabout way) to the idea of the Topps checklist, the meritocracy theory behind each set’s checklist, and whether or not it would be possible—based on a few studious hours with an old Beckett and Microsoft Excel—for me to create a checklist for an ‘average’ Topps set.

The more I thought about it, the easier it seemed to be. So this weekend, after I got back from my trip, I started. I decided to create a checklist for an ‘average’ 1960s Topps set: 598 cards complete with 12 multi-player League Leaders, 20 All-Stars, Team Cards, Special Cards and regular cards of most players with cards in three or more sets from the decade.

I started with the biggest names first (I naively thought this would be easiest): Mantle, Mays, Aaron, Koufax, Musial, Spahn, Clemente and Frank Robinson. Mays and Aaron were the easiest of these first eight. Mays was a consistent Hero Number (full hundred numbers, like 100, 200, etc.) for most of the decade (only in 1969 was he demoted to #190, a 2nd Tier Number (like 10, 20, 540, etc., though not numbers ending in 50, which are essentially Hero Numbers), with 4 years at a number ending in 50, with two years as 200 and two years in a row as 300. I gave him #150 (Koufax took #200).

Aaron was all over the map in the Topps Sixties, with four years as a 2nd Tier, one year as a 3rd Tier (numbers ending in 5) and the remaining five years a Hero Number. It was easy for me to put him at #300.

Clemente was also easy. It took Topps quite a while to acknowledge him worthy of a Hero Number (1966, #300), so because the purpose of this exercise is to create an ‘average’ set, Clemente was not given a Hero Number, but instead a 2nd Tier, #160.

Spahn and Koufax are interesting, because if you study the checklists from the Topps Sixties, it seems as though Koufax was Spahn’s heir to the Pitcher Hero Number—not Bob Gibson, who was just as deserving. Spahn and Koufax both had three years as a Hero Number, with Koufax ending his career as #100 in the 1966 set (Spahn ended his as #205, a 3rd Tier, in 1965). I gave Koufax #200 because it seems like Topps was positioning him to be the next full-set hero (to take over for the bad-kneed Mantle). Instead, Koufax retired and Topps elevated Gibson and Frank Robinson to take The Mick’s place. Spahn I gave #450.

It got interesting with Mantle, Musial and Robinson, and my decision came down to the two central ideas of my take on the Topps Numbering System: statistical superiority and institutional hero worship.

Stan Musial was in the twilight of his career in the Sixties: good, not great, he didn’t play every day;,that kind of thing. Happens all the time with players, and had he played in the 1980s and 1990s, he probably would’ve ended up with a career either like Cal Ripken (one team forever with lots of money) or like Eddie Murray: twenty-some odd years with one team and then following the money to a chain of other teams before retirement. But this isn’t the point. The point is that Topps rewarded Musial with two out of his final four years at #250 (including 1963, his last). That is some Hero Worship right there. Did he deserve #250? Probably not statistically, but in the hierarchy of the Topps Numbering System, Hero Worship beats Statistics any day of the week. So then it was obvious for me to slot Musial in at #250.

Musial proved to be just a prelude to the biggest idea of them all: should I reward Mickey Mantle Statistically or should I reward him with Hero Worship? What would Topps have done? There’s no question he deserved both, but then so did Frank Robinson, as Robinson won 2 MVPs (one in each league), won a World Series with the O’s in 1966 and was undoubtedly one of the most consistent super stars of the decade. Robinson was a Hero Number five years in the Sixties, and five years a 2nd Tier.

Topps gave Mantle a Hero Number every year except 1968 (#280), capping him at #500 in his last year, 1969. Topps featured Mantle on at least 29 different cards during the Sixties, more than any other player.

Both deserved Hero Numbers, and the two most logical open slots were #350 and #500. I ended up giving Robinson #350 and Mantle #500 because I reasoned that while #350 is almost the middle of the set, with more exposure during the pack-buying and set-building year, #500 was the Sixties Hero Worship card (like #1 was to Ted Williams in the Topps Fifties). Topps gave it to Mantle in his last year—never before. (Incidentally, Frank Robinson was #500 in 1968, even though perhaps it should have been Carl Yastzremski, winner of the 1967 AL Triple Crown (instead, Yaz got #250, his only Hero Number card in the decade).) Robinson was the statistical powerhouse of the decade, so it followed that he should get the Statistical Hero Number (#350).

After these first eight, I had a pretty good handle and could identify most of the rules and quirks of a system like this:

Levels of Numbering:

1. Hero Worship (generally one card per set, usually #500)
2. Hero Number (1, 50, 100, 150 , … etc.)
3. 2nd Tier Number (10, 20, 30, 40, 60, … etc.)
4. 3rd Tier Number (5, 15, 25, 35, 45, 55, … etc.)
5. Rookies & Late Bloomers (Common Level numbers of non-established future stars)
6. Common Level Numbers (all the other numbers)

Other Things to keep in mind:

1. No players from the same team within 7 numbers of each other
2. No players with less than three years of cards in the decade (there will be notable exceptions)
3. All-Stars based on number of inclusions across the decade
4. No expansion teams (or very few cards of expansion teams)
5. No favoritism (besides Institutional Hero Worship)

A good example of ‘No Favoritism’ is the case of Lou Brock. Look at Brock’s number for the decade:

1962 (rookie) #387
1963 #472
1964 # 29
1965 #540
1966 #125
1967 #285
1968 #520
1969 # 85

Generally it took Topps about 3 years to give a worthy player a Tiered Number. Brock was no exception, and I’m not trying to suggest that I think he was worthy of a Hero Number—he most certainly wasn’t. But I gave him #285 (3rd Tier) because of his eight cards, three were 3rd Tier; it was the most accurate thing to do. If it were up to me, I would’ve put him higher up, probably a mid-500 2nd Tier.

Now that I get deeper and deeper into this, I’m beginning to realize how long it will take to get even an ‘average’ set like this right. I’ve only just gotten my feet wet, so far as identifying and numbering 27 individual players. I will post updates as I go, finally ending with a complete 598-card checklist.

Here’s what I’ve got so far:

#20 Ernie Banks, Cubs
#30 Eddie Mathews, Braves
#65 Nellie Fox, White Sox
#70 Harmon Killebrew, Twins
#80 Richie Allen, Phillies
#90 Luis Aparicio, White Sox
#107 Rusty Staub (one of those Late Bloomer/Future Stars), Astros
#120 Pete Rose, Reds
#150 Willie Mays, Giants
#155 Roger Maris, Yankees
#160 Roberto Clemente, Pirates
#195 Joe Morgan, Astros
#200 Sandy Koufax, Dodgers
#225 Carl Yastzremski, Red Sox
#250 Stan Musial, Cardinals
#260 Don Drysdale, Dodgers
#285 Lou Brock, Cardinals
#300 Hank Aaron, Braves
#320 Bob Gibson, Cardinals
#330 Rocky Colavito, Indians
#350 Frank Robinson, Orioles
#410 Al Kaline, Tigers
#450 Warren Spahn, Braves
#470 Willie McCovey, Giants
#480 Yogi Berra, Yankees player/coach
#500 Mickey Mantle, Yankees
#510 Rod Carew, Twins


If anyone has an idea for what the design of this average Topps 1960s set would look like, send it to me by email and I’ll post the best three. I’d like to see fronts and backs, as well as League Leaders and All-Star card designs.

If ever you’ve wanted to design a baseball card and have it seen by people who care about baseball cards, this is a chance to show your idea. Just remember, designs should be able to fit well with the other sets from the Topps Sixties.

August 02, 2006

Salkeld’s Lament

I went to a wedding reception over the weekend and saw a few kids I sort of knew in high school. It wasn’t really awkward, as we had never been close, or really even friends, but both sides did sort of look the other one up and down and make judgments, I’m sure. I know I did.

This experience got me thinking in a sort of Dazed and Confused vein: If you could decide when your life peaked, at one point or another, when would it be? Would you get it over with in junior high? Or would your life be a mighty crescendo, building to when you robbed a bank at age 84 or when your band opened for a bigger band at the 9:30 Club or Arlene’s Grocery and you got your name in the music listings of The Village Voice? Most likely, you would not choose to have it happen in high school, or just after. It’s almost too cliché.

But what about Roger Salkeld? A pre-Moneyball fireballer out of Saugus High School in California, being a first-round draft pick was not meant to be a cap on his stunning high school feats, it was meant to be the rumble of a bass line announcing his arrival and your departure—back to the bench, back to the dugout, back to the minors, back to your homes, back into the night—all with one thought: Salkeld is here and we can’t remember what it was like without him.

What would’ve been more accurate would’ve been for the Score photographer to get a nice closeup of his pitching arm (and the Score copywriter could’ve written about the many ways it could get hurt), as it’s the reason Salkeld only won ten games over his short career.

Roger, what I’m trying to say is that while you may have peaked in high school and had a lousy career, you didn’t get the short end of the stick: You ended up with a handful of optimistic baseball cards. Take heart in that tonight when you howl at the moon.